Skip to Main Content

How Do I Evaluate Sources?

Scholarly? Popular? What is the Difference?

 Peer-reviewed articles are usually found in scholarly journals.

Scholarly Journals          Popular Magazines

Scholarly Journals Popular Magazines
Audience: Scholars & students Audience: General public
Author: Scholars &/or experts in the field Author: May or may not be an expert
Appearance: Few ads, lengthy articles Appearance: Many ads, colored/glossy
References: Works cited or bibliography References: References not often cited

Research Minute: How to Identify Scholarly Journals

Scholarly vs. Popular (links to tutorials)

View these tutorials that illustrate the difference between scholarly and popular publications

Popular versus Scholarly (Video)